Bones in Motion BiM Active Mobile Service Comparison Review with Garmin Forerunner 205: Introduction
Dedicated versus converged devices. The debate is ongoing. Which is better? Which one will win out? In the mobile space it's iPods versus music cell phones or text versus telephony. Things are not much different in the world of personal activity monitoring devices. Do you want distance or heart rate monitoring? Is GPS device or a foot pod accelerometer more accurate? If you want both distance and heart rate monitoring then which is more important, measuring distance or your heart rate?
In the end it always comes down to a highly subjective and personal decision. Usage model is king and compromises still rule the day. Adding to the debate is a new mobile service from Bones in Motion that combines the mobile world with personal activity monitoring via Sprint Nextel's Power Vision EV-DO network and certain GPS-enabled cell phones.
Back in February I wrote at my Mobile Analyst Watch blog about the launch of Bones in Motion's integrated BiM Active website and mobile service. Since I'm a dedicated device running geek, I was a bit dismissive of the whole thing. Fortunately, I've been participating in the Sprint Power Vision Ambassador program and consuming 3G data like it's going out of style with the Samsung A920 Multimedia cell phone. The folks at Bones in Motion graciously agreed to provide me with a pre-release version of the BiM Active Java application for the A920 handset so I could do a comparison review versus my Garmin Forerunner 205 GPS personal training watch.
Before starting, let me make it clear that I AM NOT THE TARGET AUDIENCE for the BiM Active mobile service. As I mentioned, I'm a dedicated device running geek, who wants specific features and functions, lots of data on my runs ands training, and prefers using a PC application to log and analyze the data versus online websites, such as BiM Active and MotionBased.
In my opinion, the BiM Active mobile service is geared more towards recreational athletes, especially women, who:
- like to run, bike, walk and/or hike
- want to carry a handset while exercising for safety/security purposes
- don't want or need all the functions and data of a more complex (and expensive) device
- would rather spend a monthly charge for a mobile service rather than own a device with its upfront costs
- don't obsess over having to know the absolute exact distance of their activity
WARNING: Potential users should make sure there is Sprint Nextel coverage in the area where they plan to use the service. Depending on the cell phone, BiM Active can still track GPS data if you go outside of Sprint coverage areas, but to actually start and resume an activity you have to be within Sprint's coverage area.
Here are links to the rest of the review:
- Bones in Motion BiM Active Mobile Service Comparison Review with Garmin Forerunner 205: Introduction
- Bones in Motion BiM Active Mobile Service Comparison Review with Garmin Forerunner 205: Getting Started
- Bones in Motion BiM Active Mobile Service Comparison Review with Garmin Forerunner 205: On the Run
- Bones in Motion BiM Active Mobile Service Comparison Review with Garmin Forerunner 205: Accuracy and Data
- Bones in Motion BiM Active Mobile Service Comparison Review with Garmin Forerunner 205: Review Wrap-up